What does it really take to become a goaltender?
Key Points
- Goaltending may be the toughest position in hockey because there is nowhere to hide.
- When the goalie makes a mistake, the red light comes on.
- Equipment has a limit. A $3,000 set of pads cannot give you courage. No equipment manufacturer has figured out how to put confidence inside a cardboard box.
- Sometimes the toughest opponent is inside your own head. You cannot change the goal that went in. You can change how you respond to the next shot.
By Fiorenzo Arcadi
The Toughest Position in Hockey
I have spent most of my life around hockey.
I have coached the game. I have repaired the equipment. I have owned hockey stores. I have sharpened thousands of pairs of skates and worked on more goalie pads, gloves and blockers than I could ever count. But perhaps my greatest education came from watching goaltenders.
I have seen talented goalies disappear from the game and ordinary-looking kids become extraordinary competitors. I have observed parents spend thousands of dollars trying to create talent, and I have watched kids wearing used equipment outperform them.
After all these years, I have come to one conclusion. Goaltending may be the toughest position in hockey because there is nowhere to hide. A forward can miss the net and skate back to the bench. A defender can make a mistake and sometimes his/her partner or goalie saves them. But when the goalie makes a mistake, the red light comes on. Everybody sees it. That is what makes the position so cruel. It is also what makes it so beautiful.
Younger goaltenders today know every technical expression. Butterfly. RVH. VH. Post integration. Tracking. Depth. Angles. There is nothing wrong with learning technique. The toughest position in hockey has evolved enormously, and todayโs goalies are incredible athletes. But sometimes we make goaltending so complicated that we forget the foundation. Learn how to move. Before you learn to butterfly, you need to learn how to move. Your feet matter. Your balance matters. Your edges matter. Your ability to read the play matters. The spectacular glove save gets the applause, but sometimes the best save doesnโt look spectacular at all. The goalie reads the play, moves into position and the puck hits him. People watching might think it was easy. It wasnโt. The goalie made it look easy because they were already where they needed to be. That is intelligence combined with technique.
Every aspiring goalie should watch great professional goalies, but don’t just imitate what happens when the shot arrives. Watch what happens before the shot. Look at their feet. Watch their head. Watch their depth. See how they follow the puck through traffic. Check out how they communicate. And most importantly, watch them after they allow a bad goal.
Studying professional goalies is more important than imitating them. You have to understand their process before you can perform like them. There has never been a goalie who didnโt allow one. The difference is what happens next. The great goalies donโt spend the next five minutes arguing with themselves about something that has already happened. They reset. Because the next shot doesnโt care about the last one.
Years ago, when I was coaching, I had two goalies. One came from a wealthy family. His father was a famous developer and was accustomed to getting what he wanted. He continually complained to me that his son didnโt have the right equipment. There was always somethingโ the equipment wasnโt right; the opportunity wasnโt right; his son should be playing more.
The developer was furious that I wouldn’t put his son back in the net. I didn’t care who he was. I didn’t care what he owned. I was the coach. My responsibility was to the team. Eventually the confrontation became ugly. Both the fatherโs behavior and his sonโs attitude had gotten under my skin. I lost my temper.
I wouldnโt do that today. Age teaches you that being right doesnโt excuse losing control. But I remember exactly what I said to him. โTell your son to stop the puck.โ It wasnโt elegant. It wasnโt diplomatic. But underneath the anger was something I believed deeply about sports. The position had to be earned. I told him that I believed his son was mentally weak in the net because of his father.
I also want to make one thing clear: I had nothing against the kid. My problem was with the father. Several times he approached me in the parking lot and invaded my personal space. I repeatedly told him to back off because he kept coming right up into my face. If he had stood three feet away, I could have heard everything he had to say.
I was surprised the father knew how to fight. I managed to land a few shots to his face, but my biggest concern was the other players and parents witnessing us fight. That distraction caught me off guard, and he got the better of me and knocked me out. If I had been completely focused on him, it might have been a different story.
The father eventually took his son and left the team. Later, whenever we played against the team his son joined, we beat them.
I will never forget that experience. Not because I beat a wealthy developer; that means nothing to me today. I remember it because of the other kid. The kid wearing used equipment. He never asked me why somebody else had better pads. He never asked me whose father had more money. He wanted the net. When I gave it to him, he performed. And that taught me more about goaltending than many expensive hockey schools ever could.
This might sound strange coming from someone who has spent decades in the hockey equipment business. Of course, equipment matters. A goalie needs equipment that fits properly. It needs to protect the athlete. Modern equipment has become lighter, safer and more technically advanced. But equipment has a limit. A $3,000 set of pads cannot give you courage. A new glove cannot teach anticipation. A new blocker cannot create discipline. A custom stick cannot give you resilience. And no equipment manufacturer has figured out how to put confidence inside a cardboard box.
That part comes from the goalie. Somewhere along the way, hockey began confusing buying development with developing. They are not the same thing, especially since goaltending is the toughest position in hockey.
Modern goaltending is enormously demanding physically. Goalies need strength, mobility, balance, coordination, endurance and explosive movement. But training needs a purpose. You arenโt training to look impressive in a mirror. Youโre training to stop pucks. That means taking care of the entire body.
Training matters. Recovery matters. Nutrition matters. Sleep matters. Mobility matters. Young goalies should work with qualified people who understand developing athletes rather than blindly copying workouts they see online. You can replace a broken stick. You can replace a worn-out goalie pad. You only get one body. Treat it accordingly.
The toughest opponent is inside your own head
Eventually, every goalie discovers that the toughest opponent isnโt always standing at the other end of the rink. Sometimes the toughest opponent is inside your own head. I have seen it countless times. A goalie allows a bad goal. Their shoulders drop, they start replaying it; โI should have had that.โ Then comes the dangerous thought: โI can’t let another one in.โ Now they arenโt reading the game anymore. They are protecting themselves from embarrassment. That is when one bad goal can become three. The strongest goalies learn something difficult. Forget the emotion, but remember the lesson. You cannot change the goal that went in. You can change how you respond to the next shot.
Hockey sometimes confuses confidence with arrogance. They are completely different. Ego dictates, โI’m better than everyone.โ Confidence says, โI’m prepared.โ Real confidence is built when nobody is watching. It comes from thousands of repetitions. Thousands of shots. Early mornings. Bad practices. Good practices. Losses. Mistakes. Corrections. And doing it again and again. That is the recipe for taking on the toughest position in hockey.
Eventually, the goalie doesnโt need someone standing behind the glass telling them how great they are. They know what they have put into the position. That is a much stronger form of confidence.
Every goalie loves a shutout. But I sometimes wonder whether the terrible games teach more. The game where you allow six. The game where you get pulled. The tournament where another goalie starts the championship game. The season when someone younger takes your position. The day a scout walks past you.
Those moments hurt, but they reveal character. Do you blame the defense? The coach? Your equipment? Your parents? Or do you ask yourself the most uncomfortable question in sports? What do I need to improve?
Hockey doesnโt owe anybody a professional career. You can work incredibly hard and still never play one minute in the NHL. That isnโt necessarily a failure. If the game teaches you discipline, responsibility, humility and the ability to recover from disappointment, you have taken something from hockey that can last much longer than a professional contract.
This is what has always fascinated me about goalies. Eventually they stand alone. The game may be tied with twenty seconds remaining on the clock. The arena can be screaming. Your teammates can be exhausted. The opposition can be coming at you. And suddenly the puck is released. For a fraction of a second, everything disappears.
There is only the goalie and the puck. The parents canโt help. The coach canโt help. The goalie instructor canโt help. The equipment salesperson certainly canโt help. The goalie has to make a decision.
Trust the training. Trust the eyes. Trust the body. React. That is why I have so much respect for the position. Not because goalies stop every puck. They donโt. I respect them because when they fail, everybody knows. And then they skate back into the crease anyway.
After almost a lifetime around hockey, I donโt watch goalies quite the same way I did when I was younger. I used to watch the save. Now I watch what happens after the goal. Does the goalie stare at the ceiling? Blame the defender? Smash the stick? Or do they take a drink of water, adjust their mask, skate back into position and prepare for another shot?
The toughest position in hockey and your life
Eventually life does exactly the same thing to all of us. Life scores. You lose a job. You lose an opportunity. A business fails. Someone disappoints you. Someone you love eventually leaves you. Sometimes you can do everything correctly and life still finds the top corner. There is no equipment that can protect us from all of it. No amount of money guarantees victory. No coach can make every decision for us. Eventually we all stand in our own crease.
That kid I coached many years ago probably had no idea what he taught me. He simply put on his used equipment and went into the net. No excuses. No demands. No wealthy father fighting his battles. Just a kid, a puck and an opportunity. He helped us win a championship. But the championship isnโt what I remember most. I remember that he wanted the responsibility.
Maybe that is what separates great goalies from everyone else. Not the equipment. Not the money. Not the private lessons. Not even the talent. It is the willingness to stand there knowing that eventually you are going to fail, and still wanting the next shot.
After all these years, that is my definition of a goaltender. The puck is coming again. Get back into position and stop the next one.
Fiorenzo Arcadi is CEO of Toronto Hockey Store & Goalie Heaven Ltd., a retail outlet serving the needs of hockey players in Canada and the US. His Toronto Hockey Repair Ltd. division specializes in the repair and custom manufacture of both skater and goaltender equipment.
CrossIceHockey.com is reader supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.









